More Narnia Musings

It occurred to me the other day that Lewis never stated the race of the Telmarines.  All he said was that they were pirates who roamed the south seas.  They could have been of any nationality.  But since Caspian is described (in The Voyage of the Dawn Treader) as blond, and his aunt Prunaprismia is described as red-haired, that seems to indicate European heritage.

But the Telmarines probably had south seas native heritage mixed in, as Prince Caspian says that these pirates “took the native women for wives.”  On the other hand, Lewis generally specified if someone’s coloring was darker (or in the case of the White Witch, lighter) than the European norm.  Which seems into indicate that the Telmarines may have at least looked more European than anything else.

On a different note, I’ve seen some misconceptions about the Pevensies floating around.  Namely, that Edmund is a sassy prankster, that Peter is the more level-headed, grounded one, and that Susan is the logical, down-to-earth one.  I think this is all from movie influence.  The books’ descriptions are different.  Peter, to start with, is not only bold and adventurous, he’s the one who totally understands a kid’s propensity to hide and play jokes.  He even points out how Lucy could do it better: “You’ll have to hide longer than that if you want people to start looking for you.”

Edmund, on the other hand, is straightforward (“If you’re not still too high and mighty to talk to me, I’ve something to say which you’d better listen to”), logical, and down-to-earth.  In LWW, he points out that they were following a guide they knew nothing about, and probably couldn’t get home from there.  In PC, he was bugged by the unexplained fact that Cair Paravel had become a ruin in a single year–and he’s the one who figures out the time difference between the worlds.  His plan for following the coast and the streams to Aslan’s How was incredibly simple and logical–he just forgot to factor in geographical changes because of that time difference.  (He was also still a kid; give him a break.)  In VDT, he is said to have read several detective stories, and he’s the one who pointed out the strangeness of the finding clothes and weapons scattered on one island, but no body and no bones and no signs of a fight.  Nowhere in the books do I see evidence that Edmund would be a sassy prankster; and he grew up to be a “graver, quieter man than Peter”.

Susan is practical, but not inherently logical.  In fact, in some instances, she is downright illogical; in PC, she is too afraid to see Aslan at first, even after Lucy had been twice proven right, and (as time went by) the testimony of the siblings who could see Aslan should have convinced her.

More head canons:

  • Susan loves reading her mother’s old Good Housekeeping magazines.
  • She also taught herself to knit to help the war effort.
  • Her outfits are simple and stylish, but she doesn’t pay that much attention to her looks (Lewis doesn’t describe her as focused on appearance until The Last Battle).
  • Peter is dedicated and responsible, but if a duty isn’t pressing, he pauses to have some fun with his siblings.
  • I see Peter being, not focused on his looks, but after that first trip to Narnia, a more or less neat and/or sharp dresser.
  • Edmund, by contrast, couldn’t care less about his appearance and dress, and even while a King of Narnia, favored a simpler style.
  • Edmund is somewhat bookish.
  • He also has a sweet tooth (though this is based in canon: in PC, the trees’ food looks so much like chocolate that he tries a piece of it).
  • Lucy is the only morning person of the four of them.  Edmund is the hardest to wake up in the morning.
  • Lucy goes barefoot whenever possible in the summer.
  • She also likes climbing trees.

2 thoughts on “More Narnia Musings

I'd like to hear your thoughts! But please be polite. I will not approve comments with curses, insults, or lewd remarks.