You may have figured this out already, but I don’t like the Walden Media adaptations. I enjoyed
Peter, His Siblings, and Family Is Important The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe when it first came out, but–ahem–I was 13. We’ve all done things we’re ashamed of.
By age 16 and when
Jerk Peter Prince Caspian came out, I was a bit more mature–mature enough to nearly succumb to traumatic shock at how much the story had been changed. (Am I being sarcastic? I don’t even know.)
And by age 18 when
The Voyage of Self Discovery & Multiple Aesops The Voyage of the Dawn Treader came out, I was mature enough to succumb to neither extreme and to simply laugh at it. (*whole crew sailing into mysterious green mist of ambiguous kidnapping power* Caspian: “Now is the time to be strong!” Me: “Oh, really, sir? No kidding–I never would have guessed.”)
So, that’s the confession. It leads straight into…
Those paragraphs were not the rant, believe it or not. But because I dislike the movies, I get really annoyed by movie-based depictions. I looked up Narnia fan art yesterday, and most of it was movie fan art. There’s nothing wrong with that, but I’d love to see more depictions of how the artists picture the characters. And on that note, I’d love to see more depictions of blond Caspian. Lewis in The Voyage of the Dawn Treader describes him as a “golden-headed boy” (though such a description is never given in Prince Caspian, so I understand how readers would get a different image fixed in their minds).
Anyway, it didn’t take long for me to get tired of seeing Movie-fan art. So then I looked up head canons. About 45% were movie-based, 45% were odd or just didn’t sound like the characters Lewis described, and the remaining 10% were mostly okay. It’s not a huge deal, but I want more of the book characters! In particular, I’m tired of seeing fan fics and head canons with:
- Modern-sounding dialogue
- Hidden angst in the characters
- Susan/Caspian ships
- PHOTOSETS OR GIFS OF SUSAN/CASPIAN THAT ARE NOT NECESSARILY PG RATED I AM NOT MAKING THIS UP AND I AM COMPLETELY DISGUSTED (okay, I saw this only twice, but that was one time too many)
- Unholy romantic pairings (you think Narnia escapes this? Guess again)
- Peter as the more level-headed, grounded one
- Peter’s protective nature being magnified above his other qualities
- Blond Peter
- Completely logical Susan
- Fashion/make-up loving Susan prior to The Last Battle
- Feminist Susan/defense of Susan’s behavior in The Last Battle
- Sassy prankster Edmund
- Ignorance of Edmund’s thinker, justice-focused nature
- Caspian as anything other than an earnest, cheerful, sometimes hesitant young man
The Personal Therapy
Yesterday, I began drawing my own fan art, and one piece depicts the reactions of the Pevensies and Caspian discovering fan fictions written about them. I also began writing an essay discussing Book-Peter’s personality and character arc and relationships with others. It quickly turned into a dissertation, and I shall put it in my “A Few Notes About…” series, although I’m going to try to finish Part 2 of my post about Christine Daae first.
It’s amazing how I’ve read and loved the books for 17 years and still notice new things about the story and characters. For instance, while reading through The Horse and His Boy, I noticed this about Susan: she did not rush into a marriage with Prince Rabadash. She judged him by his actions rather this appearance, race, or culture, and when she realized he was in truth spoiled, arrogant, cruel, etc., she made up her mind not to marry him. And she did so of her own initiative; her answer to Edmund’s inquiry about her decision is an unequivocal no. She’s not flighty or clueless when it comes to romantic relationships.
After Rabadash has been captured and imprisoned for unprovoked attack upon Archenland, the lords of the court mention that they are justified in executing Rabadash for his treachery. But Edmund the Just argues against this–he points out that “even a traitor may mend.” Barely two minutes later, Edmund tells Lucy that he doesn’t believe Rabadash would repent and mend–but was willing to show him mercy anyway. A second treachery, however, would not be met with such mercy.
Hopping ahead to Prince Caspian, it melts my heart that the Pevensies were the closest thing to a loving family as young Caspian had. His aunt disliked him, and Miraz, though initially willing to have Caspian inherit the throne, clearly never loved him. I wish Lewis had shown a little more of the interactions between Caspian and the four Pevensies (I posted about that here).
What’s also amazing is Caspian did not grow up bitter and angry despite his lonely childhood. He was unsure of himself, hesitant to take the throne, but–even after learning that Miraz murdered his father, after having to flee for his life, and after having to grow up quickly while barely a teenager–he remains humble, dedicated, and able to love.
He is also realistically young and adorable. For instance, though he is taught Rhetoric (mentioned in Prince Caspian) and uses it in official situations, notice how informally he speaks around the Pevensies and other comrades. He greets Eustace cheerfully and is somewhat amused by him (though this sentiment quickly fades). He is instantly smitten with Ramandu’s daughter. And he jumps overboard himself to save the three children struggling in the sea, though he could easily have ordered someone else to do it. In short–Caspian is precious and must be protected at all costs. Do not malign his character. Or I will find you. And I will kill you.
And lastly, more head canons:
- When Peter was about 15, he shot up several inches in a growth spurt, and ended up lanky for about two years. However, this did not happen as he was growing up in Narnia, because of the physical exercise he kept up.
- When a king of Narnia, Edmund usually listened to what everyone had to say and only then spoke up, usually with an armor-piercing question or very obvious solution that everyone else had missed.
- Susan learned to play the harp in Narnia, and she became quite good at it.
- Though Peter discourages any suitors unworthy of his sisters, he’s particularly protective of Lucy, since she’s the youngest, very innocent, and his favorite sister.
- In fact, he knows that Susan can hold her own, but that Lucy would be entirely too kind and sensitive to anyone obnoxious, thereby accidentally giving the wrong suitors hope.
- Lucy has no idea that she is Peter’s favorite sister. It has never crossed her mind that you can even have favorites among family members.
- Lucy likes to play outside, and she brings home anything of interest that she finds: a feather, a oddly shaped rock, and colorful pebble, an old snail’s shell, colorful leaves, bunches of flowers…
- Caspian is terrible at arithmetic. (Lewis never even lists math as one of the subjects he was taught, though he surely learned it at some point.)
- While he goes about his daily duties, Caspian often wonders what the Pevensies are doing at that moment in their world.
- Early in his reign, when he found himself confused/overwhelmed by some political matter, he found himself wishing he could consult the High King.
- Which led to the hope that just perhaps, Aslan would let the four of them return one day.
- He even began to look for them at unexpected times.
- On the other hand, Caspian did not realize it was the Pevensies (and guest) who appeared in the Narnian seas…he just saw three people struggling in open water and promptly dived overboard (like the precious, caring person that he is).
- Caspian revived the art of navigation in Narnia…by applying the astronomy principles he learned from Dr. Cornelius.
- As much as he loved his astronomy lessons, he also loves just stargazing for fun.
- During the water shortage on the Dawn Treader, Caspian actually shared some of his rations with Eustace, and Edmund shared his with Lucy (Lewis states that Edmund and Caspian had been sleeping badly since the shortage began; and given their natures, it’s conceivable they were looking out for the younger characters).